Difference between revisions of "Invasion of the Dinosaurs"

From BroaDWcast
Jump to navigationJump to search
Line 8: Line 8:
 
'''CONSPIRACY THEORY''': Where does one even begin? To make some sense of what happened with this serial, let's bullet-point the key events:
 
'''CONSPIRACY THEORY''': Where does one even begin? To make some sense of what happened with this serial, let's bullet-point the key events:
 
*'''12 January to 16 February 1974''': [[Invasion of the Dinosaurs]] airs on BBC TV.
 
*'''12 January to 16 February 1974''': [[Invasion of the Dinosaurs]] airs on BBC TV.
*'''15 January to 17 February 1974''': [[Invasion of the Dinosaurs]] airs on BBC Cymru (Wales)TV. It is understood that the original BBC transmission tapes were used.  
+
*'''15 January to 17 February 1974''': [[Invasion of the Dinosaurs]] airs on BBC Cymru (Wales)TV.  
 
*'''28 June 1974''' and '''10 July 1974''': Tele-recordings are made of episode one (and possibly also episode two).  
 
*'''28 June 1974''' and '''10 July 1974''': Tele-recordings are made of episode one (and possibly also episode two).  
 
*'''30 July 1974''': The censors in [[Australia]] view and assess [[The Time Warrior]] (on b/w film).  
 
*'''30 July 1974''': The censors in [[Australia]] view and assess [[The Time Warrior]] (on b/w film).  
Line 34: Line 34:
 
Yes, it is all very confusing. And we may never find out the answer to this one.  
 
Yes, it is all very confusing. And we may never find out the answer to this one.  
  
Okay, but for what it's worth, here's our take on this: all six original tapes were sent to Cardiff. The tape for just part one was returned to London for the sole purpose of making a tele-recording, with the intention that the others would be sent in due course. (But why just part one? Maybe the BBC wanted to re-edit the episode for foreign sale by substituting new title captions that read the full title '''"INVASION OF THE DINOSAURS"'''. But first they wanted a film copy with the original '''"INVASION"''' title for the record...) Two attempts at tele-recording were made - by inexperienced junior technicians? - to get a satisfactory film print. On the third go, the tape got damaged...
+
But, okay, for what it's worth, here's our take on this:  
 
+
* Copies of all six episodes are sent to Cardiff.  
The BBC now had an unusable video tape, three unusable film prints, and five further tapes that were now worthless. The story couldn't be sold as a black and white serial, and certainly not as a colour 6-parter. The BBC had no choice but to have the serial pulled from the foreign sale...
+
* After the BBC screenings, Enterprises starts the telerecording process. On 28 June 1974, the first telerecording is made. Unfortunately, the machine used is faulty - not only does it produce a sub-standard film recording, it also damages the tape, rendering it unplayable.  
 
+
* BBC Cardiff is instructed to send its copy of Part One back to London, which it duly does.
The other five tapes sat on the shelf in Cardiff, and were eventually returned to London sometime between November 1976 and mid-1978...
+
* On 10 July a second telerecording attempt is made, using the same machine, and unfortunately, with the same result - a poor quality film recording and a mangled tape.  
 +
* Serial WWW is now useless to BBC Enterprises, because they can't sell it as a colour story, and they are now not able to have a third attempt at getting a film copy.
 +
* August 1974. Enterprises issues a "Wipe" order, and parts two to six are duly wiped...  
 +
* BBC Cardiff eventually return their tapes of part two to six back to London sometime after November 1976 (when '''Whose Doctor Who''' was in production) and before the establishment of the Archive in 1978...  
  
  

Revision as of 06:30, 1 February 2011

Story Code: WWW / Season 11 UK Airdate: 12 Jan to 16 Feb 1974 Doctor: Jon Pertwee
First airings by location UK Repeats / Foreign Cable and Satellite Previous Story / Next Story

.

  • Although The Time Warrior was the last full story to be tele-recorded onto 16mm black and white film, at least the first and second episodes of WWW were also transferred to film.
  • However, by August 1974, only six months after the serial had aired in the UK, it was not being offered to foreign broadcasters.

WHY? That is the 1974 dollar question...

CONSPIRACY THEORY: Where does one even begin? To make some sense of what happened with this serial, let's bullet-point the key events:

  • 12 January to 16 February 1974: Invasion of the Dinosaurs airs on BBC TV.
  • 15 January to 17 February 1974: Invasion of the Dinosaurs airs on BBC Cymru (Wales)TV.
  • 28 June 1974 and 10 July 1974: Tele-recordings are made of episode one (and possibly also episode two).
  • 30 July 1974: The censors in Australia view and assess The Time Warrior (on b/w film).
  • August 1974: BBC Enterprises confirms it has no interest in selling serial WWW overseas.
  • 26 September 1974: The censors in Australia view and assess Death to the Daleks (on PAL video).
  • 10 October 1974 : The censors in Australia view and assess The Monster of Peladon (on PAL video).
  • 1974: A BBC sales 'brochure' includes Invasion of the Dinosaurs as being available.
  • 1975: A BBC sales 'brochure' includes Invasion of the Dinosaurs as being available.
  • 24 November 1976: Pre-production on Whose Doctor Who. BBC Enterprises does not hold any tapes for Serial WWW.
  • 28 February 1977: A memo is drawn up recording foreign sales of Doctor Who (See BBC Records). Invasion of the Dinosaurs is blank.
  • 1978: When the newly-formed Film and Video Archive is established, PAL video-tapes of episodes two to six are found to be held after all.
  • 1983: One of the 1974 tele-recordings of episode one is recovered early in 1983. It is of poor not-broadcast quality.

Right. That's the chain of (known) events. But what does it all mean? Given that the rest of season 11 was supplied to Australia less than six months after UK transmission, but that by that time WWW was not available, then WHATEVER IT WAS THAT HAPPENED happened sometime between 10 July 1974 (when the serial aired in Wales) and August 1974 (when Enterprises declared no further interest).

BUT WHAT DID HAPPEN?

  • The two 1974 tele-recordings were apparently of very poor quality. Maybe the reason why it was done twice was because the first did not pass the quality test. But did something happen to the original video tape of part one during this conversion process? Did the tape get mangled beyond repair after / during a third attempt to make a usable 16mm film copy?
  • It has been suggested that the two low-grade film copies were made for other reasons: one was for training purposes. Did the tape get damaged during the test session before an official tele-recording intended for foreign sales was made?
  • The BBC could have made tele-recordings of the remaining episodes and sold the serial in black and white only, but since very view countries were still buying black and white material at that time might not have justified the cost.
  • Producer Barry Letts has gone on record saying he was far from satisfied with the special visual effects; did he perhaps pull some clout and have the story withdrawn to prevent further embarrassment by pushing less-than-satisfactory product on their colonial cousins?
  • And what happened to the tapes between 1974 and 1978? It is thought that the ones found in 1978 had been returned from BBC Wales. But why did they not also return episode one?
  • And if the story was not available in any format, why was it included on two separate sales brochures? Or was this purely down to a clerical error?

Yes, it is all very confusing. And we may never find out the answer to this one.

But, okay, for what it's worth, here's our take on this:

  • Copies of all six episodes are sent to Cardiff.
  • After the BBC screenings, Enterprises starts the telerecording process. On 28 June 1974, the first telerecording is made. Unfortunately, the machine used is faulty - not only does it produce a sub-standard film recording, it also damages the tape, rendering it unplayable.
  • BBC Cardiff is instructed to send its copy of Part One back to London, which it duly does.
  • On 10 July a second telerecording attempt is made, using the same machine, and unfortunately, with the same result - a poor quality film recording and a mangled tape.
  • Serial WWW is now useless to BBC Enterprises, because they can't sell it as a colour story, and they are now not able to have a third attempt at getting a film copy.
  • August 1974. Enterprises issues a "Wipe" order, and parts two to six are duly wiped...
  • BBC Cardiff eventually return their tapes of part two to six back to London sometime after November 1976 (when Whose Doctor Who was in production) and before the establishment of the Archive in 1978...


Issue

  • The story was finally released for foreign sale in early 1985, when it was included in a package of all 24 Jon Pertwee stories.
  • However, the black and white part one was not included; the story was offered as a five-parter only. The opening titles captions were also adjusted, so PART TWO was now "PART ONE", PART THREE became "PART TWO", and so on. Part Two was also edited slightly to remove all references to scenes from part one (such as the attack by the pterodactyl).
  • The serial was sold to:
United States from Mar 85 NTSC
Australia Nov 84 PAL
New Zealand Sep 86 PAL
Canada 1990s? NTSC
  • All six parts - the black and white first instalment included - were released in later years. New Zealand aired all six episodes in a Jan 2001 repeat season.


Links