Difference between revisions of "Arabic"
Jon Preddle (talk | contribs) |
Jon Preddle (talk | contribs) |
||
(43 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
+ | {{Blank lines|1}} | ||
+ | <span style="font-size:200%;">Dubbing Doctor Who into Arabic</span> | ||
+ | |||
='''Al-Doctor Who'''= | ='''Al-Doctor Who'''= | ||
{{TOC right}} | {{TOC right}} | ||
− | + | To the Arabic speaking countries, the series was known as '''Al-Doctor Who''' (''' الدكتور هو'''). '''Al''' is Arabic for '''The''', the definite article; curiously the name '''Who''' is used and spoken as per the English pronunciation rather than being translated into the Arabic equivalent for the word "Who". | |
− | + | In Arabic script (read from right to left), the programme title is written: | |
− | |||
− | |||
− | + | <span style="font-size:250%;">{{Arabic}}</span> | |
− | + | ||
+ | When the [[New Series]] aired in the Middle East, the Arabic form of the series title logo was even able to incorporate the stylised "DW" ident: | ||
+ | [[File:ArabicTitles2010.jpg|left|thumb]] | ||
+ | {{clear}} | ||
+ | The BBC's Radio service used Egyptian actors living in London for dubbing radio plays into Arabic for consumption in the [[:Category:Middle East|Middle East]]. | ||
+ | |||
+ | BBC Radio's Arabic Service also had a production centre in Cairo, Egypt, but following the 1956 [[wikipedia:Suez Crisis|Suez crisis]], the organisation relocated to Beirut, [[Lebanon]], where it remained until the 1975 Lebanese civil war. | ||
+ | |||
+ | Due to the popularity of BBC radio programmes in Arabic countries it wasn't surprising that the BBC wanted to exploit its television programmes to the same market. | ||
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | '''WHO DUBBED WHO?''' | ||
+ | [[File:UniArt.jpg|right|thumb|350px|UniArt logo]] | ||
+ | |||
+ | The BBC employed the services of the dubbing facilities at the '''Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni Studios''' in Beirut, [[Lebanon]]. Founded in 1962, Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni was also known as [http://www.discogs.com/label/586886-Uniart-Studios UNIART STUDIOs]. <!--The Lebanese civil war forced the company to re-locate to [[Cyprus]] in 1975.--> | ||
+ | |||
+ | Because of the sheer number of variant Arabic dialects, a neo-classical form of Modern Standard Arabic was adopted for all radio and television dubs. | ||
+ | |||
+ | *[[Media:ARABIC.wav|Sample of Doctor Who in ARABIC (Audio Only)]] | ||
+ | |||
+ | But it's unclear whether the BBC themselves commissioned and arranged the Lebanese dubbings of '''Doctor Who'''; it's equally possible this was the responsibility of the first Arabic country to purchase the series, which was [[Tunisia]]. | ||
+ | |||
+ | In order for these dubs to be made, the BBC created and provided separate magnetic soundtracks that had only sound effects and music (often the scores differed from the ones that featured in the UK version, and usually consisted of stock non-copyrighted material), but no dialogue. These "M/E Track" copies were created by the BBC by mid-1966 (see interview with [[Eddie Montague]]). It was likely to be at the "M/E Track" creation stage that the decision was made by the BBC to exclude all the historical stories with the sole exception of [[The Aztecs]] from the set of episodes to have M/E tracks made. (See the [[Spanish]] page for more on this.) | ||
+ | |||
+ | The BBC supplied the dubbing studio with each magnetic soundtrack recording along with a copy of each broadcast episode – either as an English film print or on video tape which could be paused and rewound during the dubbing process for accurate lip-synching -- and a post-broadcast transcript of the English dialogue so a translation into Arabic could be prepared. | ||
=[[William Hartnell stories|WILLIAM HARTNELL]] ('''الدكتور هو''')= | =[[William Hartnell stories|WILLIAM HARTNELL]] ('''الدكتور هو''')= | ||
+ | [[File:Arabic1967Mirror.jpg|thumb|right|350px|Dr Who in Arabic, as reported in the Mirror, 1 August 1967]] | ||
− | Only nine of the first eleven [[William Hartnell stories]] ( | + | Only nine of the first eleven [[William Hartnell stories]] (40 episodes) were dubbed into Arabic: |
− | |||
{| {{small-table}} | {| {{small-table}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
− | |A||[[An Unearthly Child]]|| | + | |A||[[An Unearthly Child]]||4 |
|- | |- | ||
|B||[[The Daleks]]||7 | |B||[[The Daleks]]||7 | ||
Line 35: | Line 60: | ||
|- | |- | ||
|J||[[Planet of Giants]]||3 | |J||[[Planet of Giants]]||3 | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | | | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | | | ||
|- | |- | ||
|K||[[The Dalek Invasion of Earth]]||6 | |K||[[The Dalek Invasion of Earth]]||6 | ||
Line 42: | Line 71: | ||
|} | |} | ||
− | + | Although "M/E Tracks" had been made for [[The Dalek Invasion of Earth]] and [[The Rescue]] in 1966, the first serial was not available in 1967 due to rights issues with Terry Nation (see also the section on '''Who Dubbed Who?''' on the [[Spanish]]); this may have also affected sales of the [[The Rescue]] to Arabic stations. | |
+ | |||
+ | Therefore, only the first '''seven''' serials were available by early 1967 when they were sold to: | ||
* [[Tunisia]] | * [[Tunisia]] | ||
− | + | (These same film prints may then have been sold to [[Iran]] in late 1968; although Farsi is the principal language, the same film prints could be used with an alternative soundtrack in Farsi played in during transmission.) | |
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | [[The Dalek Invasion of Earth]] and [[The Rescue]] eventually became available again in 1968, and all '''nine''' serials were sold to: | ||
+ | |||
+ | * [[Morocco]] - by mid 1968 | ||
+ | * [[Saudi Arabia]] - by mid 1968 | ||
+ | * [[Jordan]] - by late 1969 | ||
+ | * [[Libya]] - by late 1969 | ||
+ | * [[Algeria]] - in 1973-74 | ||
− | + | ||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | |||
− | + | Interestingly, only the first episode of [[An Unearthly Child]] was screened by some (all?) of these countries. (It is known that the other three episodes of the first serial were fully dubbed, as BBC Enterprises held copies of all four instalments in that language in late 1976 – see below.) | |
− | One possible explanation for the | + | One possible explanation for the "rejection" of these three episodes is that a story set at the time of cavemen might have conflicted with the religious beliefs in some of those countries in which Islam is practised. |
− | + | There has been a long-held belief that [[The Crusade]] wasn't sold to Muslim countries because of its subject matter, and therefore some prints of the sixth episode of [[The Web Planet]] were re-edited so the '''NEXT EPISODE''' caption read '''THE SPACE MUSEUM''' rather than '''THE LION'''. However, as none of the stories after [[The Rescue]] were dubbed into Arabic or sold to Muslim countries, the change to the caption was done for other reasons (see [[The Web Planet]] page for a possible answer.) | |
− | + | ||
+ | ==BBC ARCHIVE HOLDINGS== | ||
+ | An Arabic print of part 4 of [[An Unearthly Child]] may have existed in 1973 to be used in a November 1973 edition of '''Blue Peter'''; this clip has the alternative "Music / Effects" soundtrack (compiled by [[Eddie Montague]]), but the few shots which would have had dialogue have been carefully edited out to disguise the fact that it wasn't in English. It's therefore unknown whether this print was dubbed into Arabic or [[Spanish]], or was dialogue-free. | ||
− | + | (Was this print used because when the anniversary tribute was compiled the BBC only had access to a foreign dubbed positive print and not an English copy of this serial?) | |
− | In late 1976, when the Lively Arts documentary '''Whose Doctor Who''' was being researched, the BBC still held at least the following Arabic prints: | + | In late 1976, when the Lively Arts documentary '''[[Whose Doctor Who]]''' was being researched, the BBC still held at least the following Arabic prints: |
{| {{small-table}} | {| {{small-table}} | ||
Line 89: | Line 127: | ||
|} | |} | ||
− | It has been suggested that these prints may have been returned from [[Algeria]], not long after the broadcasts had been completed in February 1974. It has also been suggested that Algeria also returned to the BBC the copies they had of the English negatives of the first two William Hartnell seasons, which had been sent to | + | It has been suggested that these prints may have been returned from [[Algeria]], not long after the broadcasts had been completed in February 1974. It has also been suggested that Algeria also returned to the BBC the copies they had of the English negatives of the first two William Hartnell seasons, which had been sent to the Algerian TV station to enable them to make foreign language dubs of the stories, and that is why those negatives survive to this day. However, we have to question that line of thought, if only for the simple fact that Radiodiffusion Television Algerienne would not have made its own Arabic dubs. Instead, they would simply have been sent a set of the pre-dubbed Arabic positives that were in circulation and had been for a number of years. (Our own thoughts as to the origin of those negatives is covered in the section on [[William Hartnell stories|WILLIAM HARTNELL]].) |
− | By late 1978, only the following were still held: | + | By late 1978, only the following were still held by the BBC: |
{| {{small-table}} | {| {{small-table}} | ||
Line 108: | Line 146: | ||
|} | |} | ||
− | + | A couple of additional episodes with Arabic soundtracks also exist in private hands, such as [[The Aztecs]] part four, which was used as an alternative language option on the DVD release of that story. | |
− | == | + | ==EXTRACTS ON VIDEO AND DVD== |
− | *[[An Unearthly Child]] part 4 - a November 1973 edition of '''Blue Peter''' (available as an extra on [[The Three Doctors]] DVD) includes clips from part 4, | + | Clips from some of the Arabic prints have featured in documentaries about '''Doctor Who''': |
+ | *[[An Unearthly Child]] part 4 - a November 1973 edition of '''Blue Peter''' (available as an extra on [[The Three Doctors]] DVD) includes clips from part 4 which have the alternative incidental music; as noted above, this would have been either dubbed into Arabic or Spanish – or possibly even dialogue-free. | ||
*[[Inside the Spaceship]] part 1 - a brief clip appears on the '''Nationwide''' interview extract on [[The Stones of Blood]] DVD release | *[[Inside the Spaceship]] part 1 - a brief clip appears on the '''Nationwide''' interview extract on [[The Stones of Blood]] DVD release | ||
*[[Inside the Spaceship]] part 2 - a brief clip appears on '''The Hartnell Years''' video | *[[Inside the Spaceship]] part 2 - a brief clip appears on '''The Hartnell Years''' video | ||
+ | *[[Inside the Spaceship]] part 2 – the Arabic soundtrack is an alternative audio option on the 2005 DVD release of the story (see below) | ||
*[[Planet of Giants]] part 1 – a brief clip appears in the 1983 US documentary '''"[[Once Upon a Time Lord]]"''', made in conjunction with station KRMA in Denver, [[Colorado]] | *[[Planet of Giants]] part 1 – a brief clip appears in the 1983 US documentary '''"[[Once Upon a Time Lord]]"''', made in conjunction with station KRMA in Denver, [[Colorado]] | ||
− | * | + | *[[Planet of Giants]] – the Arabic soundtrack for all three episodes is an alternative audio option on the 2012 DVD release of the story |
+ | *'''CLIP: Once Upon a Time Lord:''' (Arabic section at 1.39): | ||
+ | {{YouTube|float=left|id=a_aC9rfFKLE}} | ||
+ | {{clear}} | ||
− | + | *[[The Dalek Invasion of Earth]] part 6 - two clips are included in the '''"Missing in Action"''' mini-documentary from 1993 that aired before a BBC repeat of [[Planet of the Daleks]] 3 (although the first clip is erroneously attributed to being from [[The Edge of Destruction]]!) | |
− | |||
− | + | *'''CLIP: Missing in Action:''' (Arabic sections at 2.25 and 2.44): | |
+ | {{YouTube|float=left|id=ZTujXxXdaXc}} | ||
− | + | *'''CLIP: The Brink of Disaster:''' (Arabic section from 1.04): | |
+ | {{YouTube|float=left|id=LHPyiKZd3as}} | ||
+ | |||
+ | {{clear}} | ||
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | ==DVD TRANSLATIONS== | ||
+ | |||
+ | The following are translations of the narrations that accompany the opening and closing titles of the Arabic soundtracks that feature as the alternative audio options on the DVDs for [[Inside the Spaceship]] part two, [[The Aztecs]] episode four, and for all three instalments of [[Planet of Giants]]. | ||
+ | |||
+ | On all five episodes, the name of the dubbing studio "Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni" can be heard as the last words spoken in the opening and closing voice-over. | ||
+ | |||
+ | In most cases, character names and other identifiers, such the names Doctor Who, Susan, Ian, Barbara, DN6, Forester, are retained in the translations. | ||
+ | |||
+ | However, some of the detail in the dialogue has been changed; for instance in the original English, the Doctor tells Ian that his '''Ulster''' was given to him by '''[[wikipedia:Gilbert and Sullivan|Gilbert and Sullivan]]''' whereas in the Arabic, the Doctor tells Ian that his '''coat''' was like one that '''[[wikipedia:Ferdinand de Lesseps|Ferdinand de Lesseps]]''' - who built the Panama and Suez canals - used to wear. (NOTE: The Doctor's reference to de Lesseps the canal builder is in the original camera script for this episode; the origin of the Ulster must have been changed to Gilbert and Sullivan during rehearsals. But the unaltered script would have been supplied to the dubbing agency, which is why de Lesseps is named in the dubbed version.) | ||
+ | |||
+ | None of the closing narrations gives the title of the "Next Episode". Given that the giant footprint lead-in to [[Marco Polo]] is intact at the end of [[Inside the Spaceship]] part two, it would seem that no edits were made when, as in the case of this surviving [[Arabic]] edition, the story that followed did not screen. | ||
+ | |||
+ | And yet, the Arabic print held of part one of [[Planet of Giants]] contains a brief edit: the section of dialogue in which the Doctor discusses their previous adventure in the "eighteenth century" has been excised; this would have been done because the previous serial, [[The Reign of Terror]], was not part of the package sold to Arabic countries. It's not clear whether this edit was done at the dubbing stage or by one of the Arabic broadcasters. | ||
+ | |||
+ | Director Mervyn Pinfield is named in the closing narrations to the first two episodes of [[Planet of Giants]] only; no director is credited in the narration for part three. | ||
---- | ---- | ||
− | === | + | ===INSIDE THE SPACESHIP (EPISODE 2)=== |
+ | |||
*'''OPENING TITLES''': | *'''OPENING TITLES''': | ||
− | NARRATOR: '''"Al | + | NARRATOR: '''"Al Doctor Who"'''. This episode: '''Edge of Disaster'''. Written by David Whitaker. Translated into Arabic and direction of voice-dubbing by Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni. |
− | *''' | + | *'''CLOSING TITLES''': |
IAN: Does this coat suit me? | IAN: Does this coat suit me? | ||
− | DOCTOR: Yes, it does suit you. Did you know that Ferdinand de Lesseps, the man who built the canals, wore a similar | + | DOCTOR: Yes, it does suit you. Did you know that Ferdinand de Lesseps, the man who built the canals, wore a coat similar to this? |
IAN: Really? No, I didn't know that. Shall we go out now? | IAN: Really? No, I didn't know that. Shall we go out now? | ||
Line 150: | Line 215: | ||
SUSAN: Grandfather. Look. It's a footprint on the ground. It must be a monster! | SUSAN: Grandfather. Look. It's a footprint on the ground. It must be a monster! | ||
− | NARRATOR: The ship has now landed on another planet. | + | NARRATOR: The ship has now landed on another planet. We wonder - what type of adventure they will face? This is what you are going to find out in the next exciting episode of the programme '''Al Doctor Who'''. Directed by Frank Cox. Translated into Arabic and direction of voice-dubbing by Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni. |
---- | ---- | ||
− | === | + | ===THE AZTECS (EPISODE 4)=== |
+ | |||
*'''OPENING TITLES''': | *'''OPENING TITLES''': | ||
− | NARRATOR: '''"Al | + | NARRATOR: '''"Al Doctor Who"'''. This episode: '''The Day of the Darkness'''. Written by John Lucarotti. Translated into Arabic and direction of voice-dubbing by Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni. |
− | *''' | + | *'''CLOSING TITLES''': |
IAN: What's going on, Doctor? | IAN: What's going on, Doctor? | ||
Line 176: | Line 242: | ||
DOCTOR: Sure. | DOCTOR: Sure. | ||
− | BARBARA: Or | + | BARBARA: Or inside something. |
[FADE TO BLACK – THE CREDITS ROLL:] | [FADE TO BLACK – THE CREDITS ROLL:] | ||
− | NARRATOR: | + | NARRATOR: And so they rushed forward just in time as the conspirators were rubbing their hands and weaving their conspiracy. But Doctor Who managed to discover the path to escape from that silk-smooth trap that was about to ensnare them all. The engines of Doctor Who’s spaceship started, and rushed through time and space only to halt shortly afterwards. On what planet have they landed and what new adventure awaits them? This is what you are going to find out in the next exciting episode of the programme '''Al Doctor Who'''. Directed by John Crockett. Translated into Arabic and direction of voice-dubbing by Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni. |
+ | |||
− | + | ---- | |
− | |||
+ | ===PLANET OF GIANTS (EPISODE 1)=== | ||
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | *'''OPENING TITLES''': | ||
+ | |||
+ | NARRATOR: '''"Al Doctor Who"'''. This episode: '''The Giants' Planet'''. Written by Louis Marks. Translated into Arabic and direction of voice-dubbing by Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni. | ||
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | *'''CLOSING TITLES''': | ||
+ | |||
+ | NARRATOR: Even the shadows around Doctor Who and his people have turned into ashes. Death was following them, and the smell of the gunpowder was thick in the air. Can Doctor Who and his people make their way to safety and survive? This is what you are going to find out in the next exciting episode of the programme, '''Al Doctor Who'''. Directed by Mervyn Pinfield. Translated into Arabic and direction of voice-dubbing by Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni. | ||
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | ===PLANET OF GIANTS (EPISODE 2)=== | ||
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | *'''OPENING TITLES''': | ||
+ | |||
+ | NARRATOR: '''Al Doctor Who'''. This episode: '''A Dangerous Adventure'''. Written by Louis Marks. Translated into Arabic and direction of voice-dubbing by Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni. | ||
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | *'''END OF EPISODE''': | ||
+ | |||
+ | NARRATOR: And it was an adventure of a different kind, a new, different experience, a battlefield the Doctor Who has never experienced before. This time he had to fight a new type of adversary, an adversary whose weapon is a deadly substance that they want to spread on the earth to kill all living things. Will the ray of light win and beat the ashes of darkness? This is what you are going to find out in the next exciting episode of the programme '''Al Doctor Who'''. Directed by Mervyn Pinfield. Translated into Arabic and direction of voice-dubbing by Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni. | ||
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | ===PLANET OF GIANTS (EPISODE 3)=== | ||
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | *'''OPENING TITLES''': | ||
+ | |||
+ | NARRATOR: '''Al Doctor Who'''. This episode: '''The Crisis''' (*). Written by Louis Marks. Translated into Arabic and direction of voice-dubbing by Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni. | ||
+ | |||
+ | (*) This could also be translated to mean '''In Trouble'''. | ||
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | *'''CLOSING TITLES''': | ||
+ | |||
+ | DOCTOR: I might have finally discovered where we are. | ||
+ | |||
+ | NARRATOR: Doctor Who and his friends escaped from being prisoners inside the deep pipes of the lab, as it was written for them to survive. The truth of what had happened struck Doctor Who like lightning! What secrets have been revealed in front of him? This is what you are going to find out in the next exciting episode of the programme '''Al Doctor Who'''. Translated into Arabic and direction of voice-dubbing by Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni. | ||
+ | |||
+ | |||
+ | It appears that whoever wrote the Arabic narration didn't realise that the next episode was the start of a new story, and has the closing voice-over describe the next episode as the continuation of the same story. | ||
+ | |||
+ | (With grateful thanks to Fady, Rami and Rama, Aidan and Hiyam O'Donnell and Leen Al-Hadban for assistance with the translations.) | ||
---- | ---- | ||
Line 190: | Line 302: | ||
=[[Jon Pertwee stories|JON PERTWEE]] ('''الدكتور هو''')= | =[[Jon Pertwee stories|JON PERTWEE]] ('''الدكتور هو''')= | ||
+ | [[File:Arabic listing.JPG|350px|thumb|right|'''الدكتور هو''' - Al-Doctor Who, TV Listings from Lebanon for Jon Pertwee stories in 1977]] | ||
Some (but certainly not all) of Jon Pertwee's stories screened in the following Arabic countries: | Some (but certainly not all) of Jon Pertwee's stories screened in the following Arabic countries: | ||
* [[United Arab Emirates]] (from 1975?) | * [[United Arab Emirates]] (from 1975?) | ||
+ | * [[Qatar]] (circa 1977, 1978 or 1979) | ||
* [[Lebanon]] (from April 1977) | * [[Lebanon]] (from April 1977) | ||
* [[Saudi Arabia]] (from April 1977) | * [[Saudi Arabia]] (from April 1977) | ||
− | |||
− | + | Some of the Pertwee stories that played in the UAE may also have screened in [[Kuwait]], but this country is not named in any BBC records, nor have any broadcast airdates been found. | |
− | + | [[United Arab Emirates]] and [[Qatar]] broadcast only the handful of PAL colour stories that existed in their entirety, whereas [[Lebanon]] and [[Saudi Arabia]] both aired stories that were not available in that format; they must have therefore broadcast those from black and white film. | |
− | In the 1974 edition of the '''World Radio Television Handbook''' ([[WRTH]]), BBC Managing Director [[wikipedia:Huw Wheldon|Huw Wheldon]] in an April 1973 speech mentions that he had seen "Dr Who in my own office in Arabic, and a curious experience it was". | + | In the 1974 edition of the '''World Radio Television Handbook''' ([[WRTH]]), BBC Managing Director [[wikipedia:Huw Wheldon|Huw Wheldon]] in an April 1973 speech mentions that he had seen "Dr Who in my own office in Arabic, and a curious experience it was". There is no documentation to indicate that any Pertwee stories had "Music / Effect" tracks made for them (see our interview with [[Eddie Montague]] for more on this process undertaken for the Hartnell serials), so it's entirely possible that what Weldon viewed were old copies of the dubbed Hartnell episodes rather than newly-made dubs of Pertwee stories. |
− | It is known that some Arabic countries broadcast in both English and Arabic simultaneously – with the English soundtrack broadcast over the radio. | + | It is known that some Arabic countries broadcast in both English and Arabic simultaneously – with the English soundtrack broadcast over the radio, however the station in [[Saudi Arabia]] that aired the Pertwees in the late 1970s was an English-only channel. |
− | + | On this basis, we feel sure that while none of the Pertwees had been dubbed into Arabic, they may still have aired with Arabic narration and/or subtitles. | |
Line 219: | Line 332: | ||
* [[Bahrain]] (1975 and 1981) | * [[Bahrain]] (1975 and 1981) | ||
* [[Jordan]] (1981) | * [[Jordan]] (1981) | ||
− | |||
− | |||
All episodes that aired in these countries were in PAL colour. | All episodes that aired in these countries were in PAL colour. | ||
− | The [[United Arab Emirates]] broadcast Tom Baker's first two seasons on the all Arabic-language station, '''Channel 10''' | + | The [[United Arab Emirates]] broadcast Tom Baker's first two seasons on the all Arabic-language station, '''Channel 10''', with the rest on the English-only '''Channel 33'''. The Channel 10 broadcasts might also have had radio-simulcasts in English. There is no clear record that any of the Tom Baker stories had "Music / Effects" only soundtracks made for them. On this basis, we feel sure that while none of the Bakers had been dubbed into Arabic, they may still have aired with Arabic narration and/or subtitles. |
In his 1997 autobiography, ''Who on Earth is Tom Baker?'', Baker makes the observation that he is popular in [[Abu Dhabi]]. | In his 1997 autobiography, ''Who on Earth is Tom Baker?'', Baker makes the observation that he is popular in [[Abu Dhabi]]. | ||
Line 233: | Line 344: | ||
=NEW SERIES= | =NEW SERIES= | ||
− | The following link is to | + | The following link is to an Arabic blog about the [[New Series]]: |
* [http://scriptation.blogspot.com/2010/09/doctor-who.html DOCTOR WHO IN ARABIC] | * [http://scriptation.blogspot.com/2010/09/doctor-who.html DOCTOR WHO IN ARABIC] | ||
Line 242: | Line 353: | ||
*[[Broadcasts around the World]] | *[[Broadcasts around the World]] | ||
*[[Articles & Analysis]] | *[[Articles & Analysis]] | ||
+ | **[[Eddie Montague]] | ||
*[[BBC Records]] | *[[BBC Records]] | ||
*[[Doctors]] | *[[Doctors]] | ||
*[[Spanish]] | *[[Spanish]] | ||
− | + | ||
+ | __NOTITLE__ |
Latest revision as of 21:24, 9 November 2022
Dubbing Doctor Who into Arabic
Al-Doctor Who
To the Arabic speaking countries, the series was known as Al-Doctor Who ( الدكتور هو). Al is Arabic for The, the definite article; curiously the name Who is used and spoken as per the English pronunciation rather than being translated into the Arabic equivalent for the word "Who".
In Arabic script (read from right to left), the programme title is written:
الدكتور هو
When the New Series aired in the Middle East, the Arabic form of the series title logo was even able to incorporate the stylised "DW" ident:
The BBC's Radio service used Egyptian actors living in London for dubbing radio plays into Arabic for consumption in the Middle East.
BBC Radio's Arabic Service also had a production centre in Cairo, Egypt, but following the 1956 Suez crisis, the organisation relocated to Beirut, Lebanon, where it remained until the 1975 Lebanese civil war.
Due to the popularity of BBC radio programmes in Arabic countries it wasn't surprising that the BBC wanted to exploit its television programmes to the same market.
WHO DUBBED WHO?
The BBC employed the services of the dubbing facilities at the Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni Studios in Beirut, Lebanon. Founded in 1962, Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni was also known as UNIART STUDIOs.
Because of the sheer number of variant Arabic dialects, a neo-classical form of Modern Standard Arabic was adopted for all radio and television dubs.
But it's unclear whether the BBC themselves commissioned and arranged the Lebanese dubbings of Doctor Who; it's equally possible this was the responsibility of the first Arabic country to purchase the series, which was Tunisia.
In order for these dubs to be made, the BBC created and provided separate magnetic soundtracks that had only sound effects and music (often the scores differed from the ones that featured in the UK version, and usually consisted of stock non-copyrighted material), but no dialogue. These "M/E Track" copies were created by the BBC by mid-1966 (see interview with Eddie Montague). It was likely to be at the "M/E Track" creation stage that the decision was made by the BBC to exclude all the historical stories with the sole exception of The Aztecs from the set of episodes to have M/E tracks made. (See the Spanish page for more on this.)
The BBC supplied the dubbing studio with each magnetic soundtrack recording along with a copy of each broadcast episode – either as an English film print or on video tape which could be paused and rewound during the dubbing process for accurate lip-synching -- and a post-broadcast transcript of the English dialogue so a translation into Arabic could be prepared.
WILLIAM HARTNELL (الدكتور هو)
Only nine of the first eleven William Hartnell stories (40 episodes) were dubbed into Arabic:
A | An Unearthly Child | 4 |
B | The Daleks | 7 |
C | Inside the Spaceship | 2 |
E | The Keys of Marinus | 6 |
F | The Aztecs | 4 |
G | The Sensorites | 6 |
J | Planet of Giants | 3 |
K | The Dalek Invasion of Earth | 6 |
L | The Rescue | 2 |
Although "M/E Tracks" had been made for The Dalek Invasion of Earth and The Rescue in 1966, the first serial was not available in 1967 due to rights issues with Terry Nation (see also the section on Who Dubbed Who? on the Spanish); this may have also affected sales of the The Rescue to Arabic stations.
Therefore, only the first seven serials were available by early 1967 when they were sold to:
(These same film prints may then have been sold to Iran in late 1968; although Farsi is the principal language, the same film prints could be used with an alternative soundtrack in Farsi played in during transmission.)
The Dalek Invasion of Earth and The Rescue eventually became available again in 1968, and all nine serials were sold to:
- Morocco - by mid 1968
- Saudi Arabia - by mid 1968
- Jordan - by late 1969
- Libya - by late 1969
- Algeria - in 1973-74
Interestingly, only the first episode of An Unearthly Child was screened by some (all?) of these countries. (It is known that the other three episodes of the first serial were fully dubbed, as BBC Enterprises held copies of all four instalments in that language in late 1976 – see below.)
One possible explanation for the "rejection" of these three episodes is that a story set at the time of cavemen might have conflicted with the religious beliefs in some of those countries in which Islam is practised.
There has been a long-held belief that The Crusade wasn't sold to Muslim countries because of its subject matter, and therefore some prints of the sixth episode of The Web Planet were re-edited so the NEXT EPISODE caption read THE SPACE MUSEUM rather than THE LION. However, as none of the stories after The Rescue were dubbed into Arabic or sold to Muslim countries, the change to the caption was done for other reasons (see The Web Planet page for a possible answer.)
BBC ARCHIVE HOLDINGS
An Arabic print of part 4 of An Unearthly Child may have existed in 1973 to be used in a November 1973 edition of Blue Peter; this clip has the alternative "Music / Effects" soundtrack (compiled by Eddie Montague), but the few shots which would have had dialogue have been carefully edited out to disguise the fact that it wasn't in English. It's therefore unknown whether this print was dubbed into Arabic or Spanish, or was dialogue-free.
(Was this print used because when the anniversary tribute was compiled the BBC only had access to a foreign dubbed positive print and not an English copy of this serial?)
In late 1976, when the Lively Arts documentary Whose Doctor Who was being researched, the BBC still held at least the following Arabic prints:
A | An Unearthly Child | ALL |
B | The Daleks | ALL |
C | Inside the Spaceship | ALL |
E | The Keys of Marinus | ALL |
F | The Aztecs | ALL |
G | The Sensorites | ALL |
J | Planet of Giants | ALL |
K | The Dalek Invasion of Earth | ALL |
L | The Rescue | ALL |
It has been suggested that these prints may have been returned from Algeria, not long after the broadcasts had been completed in February 1974. It has also been suggested that Algeria also returned to the BBC the copies they had of the English negatives of the first two William Hartnell seasons, which had been sent to the Algerian TV station to enable them to make foreign language dubs of the stories, and that is why those negatives survive to this day. However, we have to question that line of thought, if only for the simple fact that Radiodiffusion Television Algerienne would not have made its own Arabic dubs. Instead, they would simply have been sent a set of the pre-dubbed Arabic positives that were in circulation and had been for a number of years. (Our own thoughts as to the origin of those negatives is covered in the section on WILLIAM HARTNELL.)
By late 1978, only the following were still held by the BBC:
C | Inside the Spaceship | ALL |
E | The Keys of Marinus | 1 |
J | Planet of Giants | ALL |
K | The Dalek Invasion of Earth | 1,2,4,6 |
L | The Rescue | ALL |
A couple of additional episodes with Arabic soundtracks also exist in private hands, such as The Aztecs part four, which was used as an alternative language option on the DVD release of that story.
EXTRACTS ON VIDEO AND DVD
Clips from some of the Arabic prints have featured in documentaries about Doctor Who:
- An Unearthly Child part 4 - a November 1973 edition of Blue Peter (available as an extra on The Three Doctors DVD) includes clips from part 4 which have the alternative incidental music; as noted above, this would have been either dubbed into Arabic or Spanish – or possibly even dialogue-free.
- Inside the Spaceship part 1 - a brief clip appears on the Nationwide interview extract on The Stones of Blood DVD release
- Inside the Spaceship part 2 - a brief clip appears on The Hartnell Years video
- Inside the Spaceship part 2 – the Arabic soundtrack is an alternative audio option on the 2005 DVD release of the story (see below)
- Planet of Giants part 1 – a brief clip appears in the 1983 US documentary "Once Upon a Time Lord", made in conjunction with station KRMA in Denver, Colorado
- Planet of Giants – the Arabic soundtrack for all three episodes is an alternative audio option on the 2012 DVD release of the story
- CLIP: Once Upon a Time Lord: (Arabic section at 1.39):
- The Dalek Invasion of Earth part 6 - two clips are included in the "Missing in Action" mini-documentary from 1993 that aired before a BBC repeat of Planet of the Daleks 3 (although the first clip is erroneously attributed to being from The Edge of Destruction!)
- CLIP: Missing in Action: (Arabic sections at 2.25 and 2.44):
- CLIP: The Brink of Disaster: (Arabic section from 1.04):
DVD TRANSLATIONS
The following are translations of the narrations that accompany the opening and closing titles of the Arabic soundtracks that feature as the alternative audio options on the DVDs for Inside the Spaceship part two, The Aztecs episode four, and for all three instalments of Planet of Giants.
On all five episodes, the name of the dubbing studio "Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni" can be heard as the last words spoken in the opening and closing voice-over.
In most cases, character names and other identifiers, such the names Doctor Who, Susan, Ian, Barbara, DN6, Forester, are retained in the translations.
However, some of the detail in the dialogue has been changed; for instance in the original English, the Doctor tells Ian that his Ulster was given to him by Gilbert and Sullivan whereas in the Arabic, the Doctor tells Ian that his coat was like one that Ferdinand de Lesseps - who built the Panama and Suez canals - used to wear. (NOTE: The Doctor's reference to de Lesseps the canal builder is in the original camera script for this episode; the origin of the Ulster must have been changed to Gilbert and Sullivan during rehearsals. But the unaltered script would have been supplied to the dubbing agency, which is why de Lesseps is named in the dubbed version.)
None of the closing narrations gives the title of the "Next Episode". Given that the giant footprint lead-in to Marco Polo is intact at the end of Inside the Spaceship part two, it would seem that no edits were made when, as in the case of this surviving Arabic edition, the story that followed did not screen.
And yet, the Arabic print held of part one of Planet of Giants contains a brief edit: the section of dialogue in which the Doctor discusses their previous adventure in the "eighteenth century" has been excised; this would have been done because the previous serial, The Reign of Terror, was not part of the package sold to Arabic countries. It's not clear whether this edit was done at the dubbing stage or by one of the Arabic broadcasters.
Director Mervyn Pinfield is named in the closing narrations to the first two episodes of Planet of Giants only; no director is credited in the narration for part three.
INSIDE THE SPACESHIP (EPISODE 2)
- OPENING TITLES:
NARRATOR: "Al Doctor Who". This episode: Edge of Disaster. Written by David Whitaker. Translated into Arabic and direction of voice-dubbing by Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni.
- CLOSING TITLES:
IAN: Does this coat suit me?
DOCTOR: Yes, it does suit you. Did you know that Ferdinand de Lesseps, the man who built the canals, wore a coat similar to this?
IAN: Really? No, I didn't know that. Shall we go out now?
DOCTOR: Yes, my pleasure.
SUSAN: Grandfather. Look. It's a footprint on the ground. It must be a monster!
NARRATOR: The ship has now landed on another planet. We wonder - what type of adventure they will face? This is what you are going to find out in the next exciting episode of the programme Al Doctor Who. Directed by Frank Cox. Translated into Arabic and direction of voice-dubbing by Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni.
THE AZTECS (EPISODE 4)
- OPENING TITLES:
NARRATOR: "Al Doctor Who". This episode: The Day of the Darkness. Written by John Lucarotti. Translated into Arabic and direction of voice-dubbing by Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni.
- CLOSING TITLES:
IAN: What's going on, Doctor?
DOCTOR: This is very mysterious, my boy.
IAN: What's mysterious?
DOCTOR: It's the engines. These instruments indicate that we've stopped, but these controls show we are still moving.
IAN: Maybe we've stopped on top of something.
DOCTOR: Sure.
BARBARA: Or inside something.
[FADE TO BLACK – THE CREDITS ROLL:]
NARRATOR: And so they rushed forward just in time as the conspirators were rubbing their hands and weaving their conspiracy. But Doctor Who managed to discover the path to escape from that silk-smooth trap that was about to ensnare them all. The engines of Doctor Who’s spaceship started, and rushed through time and space only to halt shortly afterwards. On what planet have they landed and what new adventure awaits them? This is what you are going to find out in the next exciting episode of the programme Al Doctor Who. Directed by John Crockett. Translated into Arabic and direction of voice-dubbing by Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni.
PLANET OF GIANTS (EPISODE 1)
- OPENING TITLES:
NARRATOR: "Al Doctor Who". This episode: The Giants' Planet. Written by Louis Marks. Translated into Arabic and direction of voice-dubbing by Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni.
- CLOSING TITLES:
NARRATOR: Even the shadows around Doctor Who and his people have turned into ashes. Death was following them, and the smell of the gunpowder was thick in the air. Can Doctor Who and his people make their way to safety and survive? This is what you are going to find out in the next exciting episode of the programme, Al Doctor Who. Directed by Mervyn Pinfield. Translated into Arabic and direction of voice-dubbing by Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni.
PLANET OF GIANTS (EPISODE 2)
- OPENING TITLES:
NARRATOR: Al Doctor Who. This episode: A Dangerous Adventure. Written by Louis Marks. Translated into Arabic and direction of voice-dubbing by Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni.
- END OF EPISODE:
NARRATOR: And it was an adventure of a different kind, a new, different experience, a battlefield the Doctor Who has never experienced before. This time he had to fight a new type of adversary, an adversary whose weapon is a deadly substance that they want to spread on the earth to kill all living things. Will the ray of light win and beat the ashes of darkness? This is what you are going to find out in the next exciting episode of the programme Al Doctor Who. Directed by Mervyn Pinfield. Translated into Arabic and direction of voice-dubbing by Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni.
PLANET OF GIANTS (EPISODE 3)
- OPENING TITLES:
NARRATOR: Al Doctor Who. This episode: The Crisis (*). Written by Louis Marks. Translated into Arabic and direction of voice-dubbing by Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni.
(*) This could also be translated to mean In Trouble.
- CLOSING TITLES:
DOCTOR: I might have finally discovered where we are.
NARRATOR: Doctor Who and his friends escaped from being prisoners inside the deep pipes of the lab, as it was written for them to survive. The truth of what had happened struck Doctor Who like lightning! What secrets have been revealed in front of him? This is what you are going to find out in the next exciting episode of the programme Al Doctor Who. Translated into Arabic and direction of voice-dubbing by Al-Ittihad Al-Fanni.
It appears that whoever wrote the Arabic narration didn't realise that the next episode was the start of a new story, and has the closing voice-over describe the next episode as the continuation of the same story.
(With grateful thanks to Fady, Rami and Rama, Aidan and Hiyam O'Donnell and Leen Al-Hadban for assistance with the translations.)
JON PERTWEE (الدكتور هو)
Some (but certainly not all) of Jon Pertwee's stories screened in the following Arabic countries:
- United Arab Emirates (from 1975?)
- Qatar (circa 1977, 1978 or 1979)
- Lebanon (from April 1977)
- Saudi Arabia (from April 1977)
Some of the Pertwee stories that played in the UAE may also have screened in Kuwait, but this country is not named in any BBC records, nor have any broadcast airdates been found.
United Arab Emirates and Qatar broadcast only the handful of PAL colour stories that existed in their entirety, whereas Lebanon and Saudi Arabia both aired stories that were not available in that format; they must have therefore broadcast those from black and white film.
In the 1974 edition of the World Radio Television Handbook (WRTH), BBC Managing Director Huw Wheldon in an April 1973 speech mentions that he had seen "Dr Who in my own office in Arabic, and a curious experience it was". There is no documentation to indicate that any Pertwee stories had "Music / Effect" tracks made for them (see our interview with Eddie Montague for more on this process undertaken for the Hartnell serials), so it's entirely possible that what Weldon viewed were old copies of the dubbed Hartnell episodes rather than newly-made dubs of Pertwee stories.
It is known that some Arabic countries broadcast in both English and Arabic simultaneously – with the English soundtrack broadcast over the radio, however the station in Saudi Arabia that aired the Pertwees in the late 1970s was an English-only channel.
On this basis, we feel sure that while none of the Pertwees had been dubbed into Arabic, they may still have aired with Arabic narration and/or subtitles.
TOM BAKER (الدكتور هو)
Some (but certainly not all) of Tom Baker's stories were screened in the following countries:
- United Arab Emirates (from 1976?)
- Bahrain (1975 and 1981)
- Jordan (1981)
All episodes that aired in these countries were in PAL colour.
The United Arab Emirates broadcast Tom Baker's first two seasons on the all Arabic-language station, Channel 10, with the rest on the English-only Channel 33. The Channel 10 broadcasts might also have had radio-simulcasts in English. There is no clear record that any of the Tom Baker stories had "Music / Effects" only soundtracks made for them. On this basis, we feel sure that while none of the Bakers had been dubbed into Arabic, they may still have aired with Arabic narration and/or subtitles.
In his 1997 autobiography, Who on Earth is Tom Baker?, Baker makes the observation that he is popular in Abu Dhabi.
NEW SERIES
The following link is to an Arabic blog about the New Series:
Links